/lIsa maiptain that the patent 131,,201 by the ,al1d .Heston pa;tent, and therefore aqd ;that the first : ,Qf the Williams ·patent 166,669, being fora,11,iwpr.oved boot, is not infril)ged by the use of the invention in the ,manufactuf.e of !\hoes. I think the defendants have failed in their attempt to show thatthe 131,201 isa repetition of the Evory and .J;Ieston,patent.. This patent was heW valid byJudgeSHU'MAN in WillY 2 Fed. .. 683., It manifest except for the tpey, have!)o l'ightJo ltPply to the IDl1nufa,cture .ofshoes a ,patented .;ill\ provement for. boots.. from thil\" consideration, it from the date .,of until after fOJ; which brppght in tqilil lJ.¢;iQn"thedefeIldantsacted,W1AI:lt:the license ./!-nd: ,itll: without Qpjection up to S,eptelAPer,30, lS86,1Pl<lltw.'not until 18S7" :that they mad,e anY:8tttfl\llPti ., .therefore s.etting up :the'in;validity, oft1)e,patepts';'J " ,; , , ,. defe.n!\e is: tlw:t:the,paten:tshave i.nfdnged. by other areduQ,lmdtPllt have the necesI1liltoP tOl,these contain,a ,lj,p pytthe: ,pl8jill,t,itTs to protect against a,l).Q ,has been depided:.by ,JUdge. Cour in t4i8 fhere ,is IlO il:»pHedcovenant that l!qq\'l Pl19teption; McKa,y V'. $rn1l,h, 39 Fed.:Q,ep. u pJn,intjffs to for Ordl,'lredaccordlngly., , : n
,is: 669.:·· "
upper; 'With; ,surpluspg,rlion in the first .claim of the Wifliama
This
166,.
u3.
; ,'.'l'
.;J'
',r '.: .: _ : I' : i
i
j.!
'"
i I ." I I, · I 1 . .; ,. ;-.
AMEl'tIO&N'FmE :HOSE !
M:Ai.NUIIl':'G ::1 .:). ';,
00. et. al. 1890.)
I'!!
.'
; " , ' :!;, ; r {QIlnoet'U. COwrli"D..
question of infringement, a preliminary : ,.;',
will not: be granted> ·
.
[,0.,
T. ·. ;,) .
,pn
. -'."
_
J
for <;Op;!. P1;altllJlll t. ;;-' ,!
J. :':.', .;
r,
, : j . J '
',' ,(JO,T.;'.Ilj,J,"i Jl.,tfi,qavits b.eforeI).le, I .do. plaintiff 9uta¢a!!lil :which, tQ'l1-. ,prellmjp,ary,injl;luction, On .th.equestion.of . conflicting, l\qd my m:iud (' c;>therJacts, ,brought out intbe llfiidfl,-
JL;'·: .:'
NATIONAL CASH REGISTER
ct>.tI.
dAfttnmIcATOR <\ R.
co.
'Ol
vits, whioh l'Iiakeit'clear that the courtsshouldl DQtgrarlt ltn injuncWtm in ,thi$'oose unless fully satisfied ·that the defendal'lts infringe the Callahan palent. This seems to be a case where it requires the full proofs, 'such as presented at final 'hearing, to properly determine the question ot'infringement. Motion'denied. '
STANDARD FOLDING·BEI> Co. fl.
KElilum d aZ. January 8, 1890)
(Oircuit 001lH'tt 'P.l'l'BN'k
87 Fed. Rep. 693.
One WMpurchases a patented article.from the ownel' oBhe patent-rlghtfor 8 certain tel'ritoI'Y. has no right to sell the same, in the c0\l1'se qf trade, in tel,Titol'r for which another owns the exclusive territorial right; ,Following Bed 00. v. KeeTm-, . '
'*'On INVilNTIONB-TEmttToBIAL RIGHTS OJ' ASSIGNBB8.
In Equity. On final hearing. E. T. Rice, Jr., for complainant. <husten Browne, for defendants. ,"I
COLT, J. I see no reason in this ease to change the conclusions on motion for Ii preliminary inreached by the court upon the junction, as! reported in 37 Fed. Rep. 693, and I shall therefore direct a complainant, as prayed for in the bill. Decree for complainunt.' '. .,"
,,- .·,
I
NATIoNAL" ." .
CASH
REGISTER Co. 'lI. BOSTON CASH INDIcATOR .. . Co. et ciZ.
&
REOORDER
(Olrcuit Oourt, D. Massachusetts. December 24, 1889.) lNVENTIONS-,!.OTION :rOB In'RINGilMBNT .....INlUNOTION AGAINST OTHEB
.... .' In a suit for Infringement of-a patent, a court of equity has the power. upon petition of defendants, to restrain complainant from bringing further suits against the '. . Ppl'9hasel's or users of the article, ,will do so when the ,'. by defmdanti show t.hat the SUIts brought are wxatlousatld oppressIve.' . .'
In' Petition by defendants, in a suit for infringement of a patent, to restrain complainant from bringing futther suits against pur, chasers of-the patented a r t i c l e . , . · ,William A. Macleod, for complainant. Frederick P. F'ishj and William K.Richardson, for petitioners and :defondants.
J. : The power of a court of equity,by petition in the main suit against a manufacturer, to restrain a complainant from brinp;ingfurthcr